Skip to main content

Resource Category: Borrowing and Debt

In the United States, borrowing can be a key means for investing in one’s family and future, including for common household investments like college tuition and home mortgages. However, borrowing has also been subject to discriminatory and predatory practices, leading debt to sometimes be used as a tool of wealth extraction rather than wealth creation.

Resource Summaries

Report December 2023

Wealth Surged in the Pandemic, but Debt Endures for Poorer Black and Hispanic Families

By Rakesh Kochhar, Mohamad Moslimani

Using newly released data from the Survey of Income and Program Participation, Pew finds that wealth grew for most American households from 2019 to 2021, in part likely a result of new and expanded government support programs during the pandemic. Data from this new SIPP analysis are less current than data from the Survey of Consumer Finances, which goes up to 2022, but the SIPP sample size is larger, allowing for more detailed demographic analysis.

Using newly released data from the Survey of Income and Program Participation, Pew finds that wealth grew for most American households from 2019 to 2021, in part likely a result of new and expanded government support programs during the pandemic. Data from this new SIPP analysis are less current than data from the Survey of Consumer Finances, which goes up to 2022, but the SIPP sample size is larger, allowing for more detailed demographic analysis.

The authors find that this overall growth helped close wealth gaps between and within racial groups across the pandemic, and that of all groups, the gap between richer and poorer Black households closed the most. While proportional wealth gaps closed for most groups, most of the increases in real dollar terms still accrued to richer households. Further analyses in this report focus on breaking out households by asset class and value, and the finding that the 60 percent of wealth held by Black and Hispanic homeowners is thanks to the equity they have in their homes.

Summary July 2023

Disparities in Debt: Why Debt is a Driver in the Racial Wealth Gap

By Jen Mishory, Mark Huselman

This Aspen Institute report uses data from the Survey of Consumer Finances to analyze levels and types of debt held by different racial groups in America. Notably, it’s one of a select few reports that includes data on Asian Americans and American Indians.

This Aspen Institute report uses data from the Survey of Consumer Finances to analyze levels and types of debt held by different racial groups in America. Notably, it’s one of a select few reports that includes data on Asian Americans and American Indians.

The authors find that while Asian households have similar wealth to White households, they tend to carry more debt. They also note large differences across different Asian subgroups, with significant wealth differences between, for example, Japanese and Filipino households. Authors also find that certain forms of debt can be a major hindrance towards wealth building, especially for Black Americans.

To address the differential impact on communities of color from debt and provide resources for wealth building, the authors have several recommendations. These include canceling student debt, increasing access to high-quality mortgages for people of color, and reducing medical debt by increasing access to affordable health care. One final recommendation revolves around eliminating most public fines and fees that result in debt. These often fall on populations of color and in certain circumstances can lead to prison time.

Summary June 2023

Forced to Walk a Dangerous Line: The Causes and Consequences of Debt in Black Communities

By Andre M. Perry, Joia Crear-Perry, Carl Romer, Nana Adjeiwaa-Manu

This report by Prosperity Now finds that while the share of Black and White households with debt is relatively similar (at 77 and 78 percent respectively), the cost and utility of that debt can vary greatly. Overall, nearly two-thirds of Black households find it difficult to cover their bills, and over a quarter report having made late payments. By contrast, just under half of White households reported difficulty covering their bills, while just 15 percent have been late making payments.

This report by Prosperity Now finds that while the share of Black and White households with debt is relatively similar (at 77 and 78 percent respectively), the cost and utility of that debt can vary greatly. Overall, nearly two-thirds of Black households find it difficult to cover their bills, and over a quarter report having made late payments. By contrast, just under half of White households reported difficulty covering their bills, while just 15 percent have been late making payments.

The report ends with some suggestions for tackling these disparities. The authors recommend expanded community-based debt-relief and coaching services, as well as the creation of state offices dedicated towards financial education, credit and debt management. Authors also argue that the federal government should affirmatively protect households against wealth-stripping practices and create opportunities for wealth growth such as introducing a savings program to an expanded Earned Income Tax Credit.

Summary April 2023

How Student Debt and the Racial Wealth Gap Reinforce Each Other

By Andre M. Perry, Joia Crear-Perry, Carl Romer, Nana Adjeiwaa-Manu

This Century Foundation report finds that due to long-standing systemic inequities, Black students typically have less familial wealth to call upon as they seek a college education, and consequently are forced to rely more on debt financing. This does not mean they hold the most debt overall, but rather that their mix of funding relies more on debt than other students. Indeed, Black students sometimes take on riskier forms of debt, leading them to be more likely to default and have higher payments and debt balances.

This Century Foundation report finds that due to long-standing systemic inequities, Black students typically have less familial wealth to call upon as they seek a college education, and consequently are forced to rely more on debt financing. This does not mean they hold the most debt overall, but rather that their mix of funding relies more on debt than other students. Indeed, Black students sometimes take on riskier forms of debt, leading them to be more likely to default and have higher payments and debt balances.

Authors propose some solutions to these particularly thorny problems, though they remain relatively high-level. One significant first step that authors emphasize is bringing down the cost of tuition. By going up stream to reduce the baseline cost of college for all students, higher education would become more accessible for everyone and would ultimately be especially helpful in reducing the debt levels of Black students, who currently are more likely to have student debt.

More On This Topic

Report 2021

The racial implications of medical debt: how moving toward universal health care and other reforms can address them

By Andre M. Perry, Joia Crear-Perry, Carl Romer, Nana Adjeiwaa-Manu

ReadThe racial implications of medical debt: how moving toward universal health care and other reforms can address them on Brookings
Report 2021

Jim Crow Debt: How Black Borrowers Experience Student Loans

By Jalil Bishop, Jonathan Davis

ReadJim Crow Debt: How Black Borrowers Experience Student Loans on The Education Trust
Report 2019

Overdue: Addressing Debt in Black Communities

By Spectra Myers, Pamela Chan

ReadOverdue: Addressing Debt in Black Communities on Prosperity Now
Report 2019

Millennials and Student Loans: Rising Debts and Disparities

By Wesley Whistle

ReadMillennials and Student Loans: Rising Debts and Disparities on New America